By Beth M. Rivers In a groundbreaking decision, the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit has ruled that workplace discrimination based on sexual orientation violates federal civil rights law. In Hively v Ivy Tech Community College of Indiana, 853 F3d 339 (7th Cir 2017) the court found that such discrimination is a form of sex discrimination in violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the federal law which prohibits employers from discriminating against employees on the basis of sex, race, color, national origin and religion. This is the first time that a federal court of appeals had reached this conclusion and could potentially change the national and local landscape of employment law for LGBT people. Although courts have been reluctant to expand the protections of Title VII and the Elliott-Larsen Civil Rights Act to include sexual orientation claims, some Michigan and federal courts have used a gender-stereotyping theory to litigate claims of sexual orientation discrimination. However, the EEOC has recognized sexual orientation as a protected class since 2015 and has successfully pursued charges of sex discrimination based on sexual orientation. Now a court of appeals have also recognized the validity of such a claim. In Hively the plaintiff sued her employer arguing that the school violated Title VII when it denied her full-time employment and promotions after she had been seen kissing her then-girlfriend. In its decision, the Court of Appeals concluded that discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation constitutes impermissible discrimination on the basis of sex – which is one of the specifically protected categories under Title VII. In reaching this result, the Court rejected any distinction between sex discrimination based on sexual orientation and sex discrimination based on gender stereotyping noting that while courts have previously “described the line between a gender nonconformity claim and one based on sexual orientation as gossamer thin, we conclude that it does not exist at all.” The Court explained that Hively’s claim is no different than any other gender stereotyping claims brought by women who were rejected for job in traditionally male workplaces, such as fire departments, construction and policing as the employers in those cases were policing the boundaries of what jobs or behaviors they found acceptable for a women. Likewise discrimination based on sexual orientation flows from the premise that all men should date or marry women and that all women should date or marry men. As such, it is precisely the LGBT employee’s sex, i.e. gender, that precipitates discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation. In short, according to the Court, sexual orientation discrimination is sex discrimination and thefore Hively was permitted to proceed with her claim. While the Hively decision technically only applies to employees in the Seventh Circuit, which includes the states of Indiana, Illinois and Wisconsin, this decision along with the position of the EEOC, has established a foothold which hopefully will be followed by additional federal courts and state courts including Michigan.
Megan Bonanni was cited by the Detroit Free Press in coverage of new Nassar victims and September 10 deadline for filing civil suits
Megan Bonanni was cited by MLive in its coverage of legal representation for new Nassar victims and pending deadline for filing civil suits
Michael Pitt discusses his social justice background and motivation in an announcement posted by Public Justice on his selection as its president for a one-year term
M. Pitt was cited by MLive in its coverage of August 1 U.S. District Court ruling on Flint class action
Michigan Radio/NPR -- "Flint Water Class Action Lawsuit Moves Forward, but Gov. Snyder Dropped as Defendant"
Michael Pitt and Ted Leopold were cited by Michigan Radio/NPR in its story on Judge Levy's ruling in the Flint class action:
Mike Pitt and Ted Leopold were quoted in WLUC/NBC/Upper Michigan's coverage of the federal court ruling in the Flint Class Action:
Mike Pitt was cited in a Detroit News story on the Flint Class Action ruling
Ted Leopold and Mike Pitt were cited in the National Law Journal's coverage of federal court decision in Flint class action:
Michael Pitt was quoted in a Legal News story on the firm's new Nassar cases and approaching deadline for making related claims:
Michael Pitt was interviewed on July 19, 2018 by Cynthia Canty on Michigan Radio's Stateside program regarding the firm's representation of Nassar victims, details relating to the Nassar Victim Fund(s) and new state laws reviving time-barred civil claims
Michael Pitt was cited in Michigan Radio/NPR coverage of July 11 hearing on Flint class actions
Mike Pitt was interviewed by WJRT/ABC 12/Flint in two linked segments reporting on the July 11 Ann Arbor hearing regarding Flint Water Crisis-related class action lawsuits
Michael Pitt was quoted in MLive coverage of July 11 hearing on Flint water crisis-related class actions
WNEM/CBS/Flint-Saginaw -- "Defense Attorneys Argue Class Action Lawsuits for Water Crisis are Invalid"(2:03)
Flint legal team member Bill Goodman was interviewed by television station WNEM/CBS at July 11 hearing in Ann Arbor.
Mike Pitt was cited by Detroit News in its coverage of July 11 hearing on Flint water crisis-related class action lawsuits.
Michigan Radio/NPR -- "Federal Judge to Consider Requests to Dismiss Flint Water Crisis Class Action Lawsuit"
Michael Pitt was cited by Michigan Radio/NPR in a news report on the upcoming July 11 U.S. District Court hearing on Flint Water Crisis-related class action lawsuits.
M. Pitt & R. Wagner were cited by MLive in its coverage of two complaints the firm has filed in Genesee County Circuit Court
MLive -- "Deadly State Police Cases More Likely in Black Communities, Lawsuit Claims"
The Oakland Press -- "Royal Oak Attorney Wins Champion of Justice Award"
Legal News reported Michael Pitt's selection as MAJ's Champion of Justice
Jennifer Lord was cited by Crain's Detroit Business (June 11 edition) in its coverage of the Tim Leuliette severance-pay scandal